Detailed Analytical Comparison of Project-76 With Project-75I And Project-75 Submarines

Project-76 is an ambitious Indian Navy program to build 12 advanced
conventional submarines, with the first prototype expected around 2030. These
are indigenous diesel-electric submarines equipped with Air-Independent
Propulsion (AIP) and estimated to have a submerged displacement around 3,000
to 4,000 tonnes, marking a significant leap in size and endurance from
previous classes.
Project-76 subs will feature key technologies such as pump-jet propulsion for
enhanced stealth and efficiency, lithium-ion batteries, and a fully indigenous
weapon control system. The design also draws on experience and technology from
India’s upcoming nuclear attack submarines under Project-77, aiming for a high
share (up to 80%) of indigenous components.
This project is focused on reducing dependency on foreign designs while
enhancing underwater endurance and operational versatility in contested
environments.
Project-75, also called the Kalvari-class, involved the construction of six
Scorpene-class diesel-electric attack submarines in collaboration with the
French Naval Group and Indian shipyards. These subs displace about 1,700 tons
submerged, are equipped with conventional diesel-electric propulsion with some
integration of AIP technology, and feature wire-guided torpedoes and
tube-launched anti-ship missiles.
Project-75 marks India’s first major indigenous submarine production effort
with technology transfer, aimed at modernizing the underwater fleet with
stealth and advanced sensors, but with a smaller size and less underwater
endurance compared to later projects.
Project-75I (India) is a follow-up to Project-75, aiming to build six advanced
conventional submarines with foreign design collaboration but greater
indigenous construction. These subs will be larger than the Project-75 boats,
with an expected displacement of about 3,000 tonnes, and equipped with
Air-Independent Propulsion systems for substantially enhanced underwater
endurance.
P-75I integrates newer generation sensors, ISR (Intelligence, Surveillance,
Reconnaissance) capabilities, and advanced weapons suites including
land-attack cruise missiles, anti-ship missiles, and heavyweight torpedoes. It
fills the capability gap between the smaller Project-75 and the much larger
nuclear attack submarines under Project-77. Its design also emphasizes stealth
and operational flexibility in diverse maritime roles.
The primary distinctions lie in displacement, propulsion, stealth, and
indigenous content: Project-75 set the foundation with smaller Scorpene-class
diesel-electric subs; Project-75I scales up with more advanced AIP-enabled
diesel-electric subs of about 3,000 tons, stronger indigenous content, and
enhanced combat systems; Project-76 further leaps ahead with larger
(3,000–4,000 tons) submarines featuring pump-jet propulsion, lithium-ion
batteries, full indigenous design, and technologies derived from nuclear
submarine programs, aiming for superior underwater endurance, stealth, and
multirole operational capabilities.
These programs represent a continuum toward greater self-reliance and enhanced
submarine warfare capabilities for the Indian Navy in the coming decades.
This layered approach strategically balances immediate fleet modernization
(P-75), mid-term advanced capability upgrade (P-75I), and long-term high-end
indigenous technology-driven capability (P-76) for comprehensive maritime
dominance. Each project progressively incorporates newer technologies, greater
indigenous manufacturing, and larger platform sizes to meet evolving maritime
security challenges.
| Aspect | Project-75 | Project-75I | Project-76 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Build six Scorpene-class conventional diesel-electric submarines with technology transfer from France (Naval Group). | Build six advanced conventional submarines with Air Independent Propulsion (AIP) and foreign design support under the Strategic Partnership model. | Build 12 fully indigenous diesel-electric submarines with AIP, advanced stealth, and weapon systems developed domestically. |
| Indigenous Content | Moderate (~40-50%) via technology transfer for construction in India. | Higher indigenous content (45%-60%) focusing on newer tech and local manufacturing. | Very high indigenous content (~90-95%) with domestic design, weapon control, and lithium-ion battery integration. |
| Air Independent Propulsion (AIP) | Not equipped (traditional diesel-electric). | Equipped with AIP fuel-cell systems that enable about two weeks submerged endurance. | Equipped with indigenous AIP system from DRDO for enhanced endurance and stealth. |
| Displacement | Approx. 1,500-1,700 tons (Scorpene-class). | Larger than Project-75 subs, ~3,000 tons. | Approximately 3,000 tons submerged displacement, next-gen capabilities. |
| Manufacturing | Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders (MDL) with French collaboration. | Indian shipyards with foreign OEM design support (Germany's ThyssenKrupp or Spain’s Navantia). | Larsen & Toubro (L&T) leading indigenous design and build with DRDO collaboration. |
| Operational Timeline | First delivery by mid-2020s, operational by late 2020s to mid-2030s. | Expected delivery between late 2020s and mid-2030s (delayed). | Design completion by 2027, construction start ~2030, commissioning by 2037. |
| Key Features | Stealth technologies and modern torpedoes/missiles but no AIP. | Advanced sensors, stealth, cruise missile capability, AIP, and ISR systems. | Indigenous weapon control system, lithium-ion batteries, cruise missile strike capability, and strong stealth. |
| Strategic Significance | Foundation of modern Indian conventional submarine force. | Next stage in capability with modern tech and higher self-reliance. | Leap towards full indigenous underwater naval capability with emphasis on strategic autonomy and export potential. |
Project-75 introduced Scorpene submarines with moderate indigenous content and no AIP. Project-75I improves on Project-75 by adding AIP and modern combat systems with foreign design support but higher indigenous manufacture.
Project-76 is the most ambitious, aiming for near-complete indigenous design and build with the latest technologies and advanced weapon systems, representing a major step toward India’s strategic and industrial self-reliance in submarine capabilities
IDN (With Agency Inputs)
No comments:
Post a Comment