Numbers Don’t Lie: MiG-21 Proved Safer Than Its Reputation, Data Debunks ‘Flying Coffin’ Myth
The MiG-21, inducted into the Indian Air Force (IAF) in the early 1960s, was
officially decommissioned after serving for more than six decades. Despite
being unfairly branded with terms like “flying coffin” and “widow-maker,”
newly presented data confirms it was one of the safest fighters in the IAF’s
inventory. The fighter was phased out not because of safety issues, but
because its technical life had come to an end, reported Ajay Sura of TOI.
Former IAF chief Air Chief Marshal B S Dhanoa (Retd) revealed that the MiG-21
had logged 15,84,522 flying hours with 468 accidents, translating into an
accident rate of 2.95. This figure is comparable to the MiG-23 (2.95) and
MiG-27 (3.04), while being lower than the Hunter (4.26) and the Gnat (6.88).
The numbers clearly prove that the MiG-21’s safety record does not align with
the negative perception created over time.
The reputation of the MiG-21 as a “flying coffin” largely stemmed from its
long service life and the inevitable attrition of aircraft operating in large
numbers over decades. Nearly every IAF fighter from the 1960s through the
1990s witnessed accident rates at different times, but the MiG-21 became a
particular target because of its ubiquity in the fleet.
Dhanoa stressed that
unlike the U.S.-made F-104 Starfighter, which was retired due to genuine
safety concerns, the MiG-21 is being withdrawn purely because it has reached
the limit of its operational life cycle.
During the final ceremony marking its retirement, the commanding officers of
No. 23 and No. 28 Squadrons presented the Form 700 logbooks to the Chief of
Air Staff. This exhaustive record of every repair, inspection, and maintenance
performed on the aircraft symbolised the end of service for the supersonic
icon. The handover represented closure for a jet that was once the backbone of
India’s air defence for decades.
The MiG-21 leaves behind an unmatched combat record in the subcontinent. It
played decisive roles in the 1971 India-Pakistan War, where it downed several
adversary aircraft, and continued to be relevant in later conflicts. Notably,
in 2019, it made international headlines when a MiG-21 Bison piloted by Wing
Commander Abhinandan Varthaman shot down a Pakistani F-16 during the Balakot
airstrike aftermath. This cemented its reputation as the “F-16 Killer” and
highlighted how modernisation and pilot training had kept the jet formidable
even in the 21st century.
For generations of IAF pilots, the MiG-21 was more than a machine — it was a
gateway into high-performance supersonic combat. Pilots often described their
bond with the aircraft as deeply personal, recalling its raw speed, agility,
and resilience. Its design simplicity, adaptability, and combat-proven record
ensured that it shaped Indian air doctrine for decades.
The MiG-21 thus signs off with dignity, remembered not as a “flying coffin,”
but as an enduring legend that defined India’s air power through wars, crises,
and deterrence. It retires as a symbol of resilience, service, and unmatched
historical significance for the Indian Air Force.
Below is a tabular comparison of the accident rates and service records for
the MiG-21 and its contemporary Indian Air Force fighters. This summarises
their relative safety and operational scope based on the latest official data.
| Aircraft Type | Total Flying Hours | Accidents | Accident Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| MiG-21 | 1,584,522 | 468 | 2.95 |
| Gnat | Not Available | 92 | 6.88 |
| Hunter | Not Available | 86 | 4.26 |
| MiG-23 | Not Available | 69 | 2.95 |
| MiG-27 | Not Available | 64 | 3.04 |
This table demonstrates that the MiG-21’s accident rate is among the lowest in its class, supporting official statements that it was one of the safest fighters in the IAF inventory and debunking the “flying coffin” narrative.
Based On TOI Report
No comments:
Post a Comment